A Battle of Durability and Style: Rocky S2V vs Redwing Heritage boot reviews

Check out the reviews and comparisons for the Rocky S2V boots vs Redwing Heritage and you decide which is best for your feet.

In the world of rugged footwear, two brands have cemented their reputation as go-to options for those seeking durability, reliability, and style: Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage Boots. Both brands boast a rich history of providing high-quality boots for outdoor enthusiasts, workers, and fashion-conscious individuals. In this comparison review, we’ll explore the key features of the Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage boots to help you make an informed decision about which pair suits your needs.

Durability and Construction:
When it comes to durability, both the Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage boots are built to last. The Rocky S2V boots are engineered for the military, ensuring exceptional ruggedness and longevity. Constructed with top-notch materials like full-grain leather and Cordura nylon, they offer excellent abrasion resistance and protection against the elements. The triple-stitched construction and robust Vibram outsole further enhance their durability.

On the other hand, Redwing Heritage boots have gained a reputation for their exceptional craftsmanship. These boots are handcrafted in the USA using premium leathers and meticulous attention to detail. Redwing’s Goodyear welt construction technique ensures durability, making it easy to resole the boots when needed. While not specifically designed for military use, the Heritage line exhibits outstanding quality and longevity.

Comfort and Fit:
Both Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage boots prioritize comfort and fit, albeit with slightly different approaches. The Rocky S2V boots are designed to provide all-day comfort, even in demanding situations. They feature a padded collar, cushioned footbed, and a supportive, contoured insole. The boots also have a moisture-wicking lining to keep your feet dry during extended wear.

Redwing Heritage boots, on the other hand, offer a more traditional feel. The high-quality leather used in their construction molds to the wearer’s feet over time, resulting in a personalized fit. While they may require some break-in period, the investment pays off with unmatched comfort and support as the boots conform to your feet.

Style and Versatility:
Style is where the Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage boots diverge significantly. The Rocky S2V boots exude a more utilitarian and tactical aesthetic, tailored for military and outdoor activities. They have a rugged, robust appearance that appeals to those seeking a functional and reliable boot without compromising on style.

In contrast, Redwing Heritage boots offer a timeless, classic style that transcends trends. With their clean lines, rich leather finishes, and attention to detail, these boots are equally at home in a casual or formal setting. They lend a touch of heritage and sophistication to any outfit, making them a versatile choice for the fashion-conscious individual.

Price and Value:
Price is an important consideration for many buyers, and both the Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage boots fall into the higher price range. The Rocky S2V boots justify their price with their military-grade durability and performance, making them an excellent investment for those in need of heavy-duty boots. Redwing Heritage boots, while pricier, offer a premium experience with their handcrafted quality and timeless style.

Rocky S2V Boot Review
I purchased a pair of these boots while I was serving on active duty U.S. Army service member stationed at Ft Bragg in North Carolina.  I have worn numerous types of boots from the ever popular Danner  to the less commonly seen Nikes. Having a good set of boots is a top priority for all service members. Being able to ruck march for long periods of time with large amounts of wieght is an essential ability in my line of work.

RedWing Heritage Boots Review
So now that I’ve had these boots for about a month, I figured it’s time for me to weigh in. The Red Wing Heritage Boots are high quality boots. The leather just feels legit. I’ve got some other very nice leather boots and shoes and these boots surpass them all in leather quality. The leather is thicker, yet supple. The entire boot feels well-constructed.

The stitching is top notch. The soles should last forever (c’mon, they’re Vibram!) and if they don’t they could easily be replaced. I’ve gotten compliments from both hipsters and true-blue working class dudes alike. The verdict is in: these boots are the real deal.

Rocky S2V Boot Review
Don’t change sizes. I wear a size 12 in Nike, and these fit like gloves. Really the most comfortable boots that I’ve ever worn. So far, I’ve worn them for a full 24 hours straight and walked at least 5 miles in them. I wore nike synthetic padded socks with them, and only started to feel a slight bit of heel tenderness near the end due to the fact that I’m still breaking them in. They were brand new when I put them on, so I imagine them only getting better from here. I highly recommended the Rocky S2V Work Boot. They fit perfect, at least for me, and I tried Danner, Belleville, and some others. These were the best, by far for my use.

Choosing between the Rocky S2V and Redwing Heritage boots ultimately comes down to personal preference and intended use. If you prioritize military-grade durability, excellent traction, and a utilitarian look, the Rocky S2V boots are the clear choice. On the other hand, if you value handcrafted quality, timeless style, and a personalized fit, the Redwing Heritage boots are hard to beat.

Both boots excel in their respective areas, and either choice will provide you with a reliable and stylish pair of boots that can handle a variety of environments and situations.

Question: Are Danner boots really used in the military?

Yes; Danners are issued to U.S. Army Rangers.

Garmin Oregon 450t GPS Review
Danner Desert Acadia 400g Boot Review
Top 10 Special Forces boot reviews
Lowa boots vs Danner

Seal Fit Stack

SGPT Upcoming Events

Personal Online Coaching

Work 1-on-1
with SEAL Grinder's Brad McLeod
To Achieve Your Goals

pic of brad

Personal fitness training from Brad McLeod, Navy Seal and CrossFit Level 1 instructor. Delivered online, directly to you.

"I recommend Brad to anyone that seriously wants to go to BUDs or anything else in life... try these workouts. Hooyah!" - Chris H.

learn more button